Your monitoring tool says everything is fine—200 OK everywhere. But your users? They’re staring at a blank screen or broken layout. Welcome to the world of false positives in API monitoring.

What Is a “False OK” in API Monitoring?

An API endpoint returning a 200 status code doesn’t always mean the system is healthy. It simply means the server responded. What if the payload is empty, the data is outdated, or a third-party dependency silently failed?

An API dashboard showing 200 OK status while visually broken — symbolizing false positives.

Common Cases of Broken but “OK” APIs

Empty success: API responds with 200 but returns no usable data.
Outdated cache: API serves cached responses even when the backend is down.
Silent fallback: Third-party service fails, but your system masks it with default data.
Partial failure: Multi-step APIs return partial data with success code.

Why Synthetic Checks Aren’t Enough

Traditional monitoring often stops at checking HTTP status codes. But that’s not enough. What really matters is:

Is the data correct?
Is the response complete?
Does the payload meet expectations?

How Functional Checks Save You

Functional API monitoring means checking not just if an endpoint responds, but also if it behaves as expected:

Verify key fields exist and are not empty
Validate response schema
Check content freshness
Monitor actual user journeys through chained requests

A split view showing trusted API responses on one side and backend failures on the other.

How Watchman Tower Helps

At Watchman Tower, we go beyond simple status checks. Our API monitoring allows you to:

Create rules to validate data and fields
Get alerts on schema mismatches or content issues
Chain requests to simulate real workflows

✅ Stop trusting 200 OK blindly. Start monitoring what truly matters.

Explore our API Monitoring Blogs

When APIs Say “I’m OK” But They’re Not: ...

How We Monitor APIs: A Real-World Exampl...